Chapter 6

• When we got up everyone around us was just finishing fucking and were grabbing their things and leaving. By now my buzz was completely gone, so I pulled my pants up and grabbed a quick drink and went and sat on the couch, and was soon joined by Matt who just finished fucking Supergirl.
• “Dude, this was the best party ever! I got so much ass tonight.”
• “I never would've thought I would get laid at a Halloween party, man I'm glad I came.”
• “I knew you would, Terra and Stacey are glad you came too.”
• “They left before the name thing started, but yea it was definitely fun while they were here.”
• “Left? They didn't leave, they just changed costumes.”
• “Huh? What they change into?”
• As soon as I said that the two cat girls came and sat down on either side of me. They had washed the paint off their face and took off the fake nose and ears, it was Terra and Stacey.
• “I just had a threesome with two of my best friends? Why didn't you tell me it was you guys?”
• Because we knew you wouldn't do anything with us. We wanted to experiment with you for a while now, but I didn't plan on fucking you until I saw your huge cock, I had to have it in me,” Terra said.
• “By the way, thank you for eating my pussy so good, this definitely wont be the last time,” Stacey said.
• It took me a while to get used to the fact I just had sex with my friends, but they helped me warm up to it by reassuring me we would be doing it a lot more. By now everyone was gone and his place was trashed, so we volunteered to help him clean before we left. After we helped Matt clean up we kissed the girls goodbye as they left to go home, Terra grabbed my cock as she kissed me on the lips.
• “If we didn't have to leave I'd fuck you again right now. Next time you'll have to eat my pussy, I wanna feel what you made Stacey feel,” she said as she kissed me one more time and left.
• I figured I should get home too before it got too late, so I went back to the room Batgirl and I were in to get the hat and sword, only to find it gone. Somebody stole it? What the hell? My sister was gonna kill me. I told Matt and he said he'd look around for it, but not to hold my breath. I thanked him as I left and got in my car and drove home.
• I got home to find our parents still gone, but I saw the light on in my sisters room, so I thought I'd tell her about the sword now and get it over with.
• (knock knock knock) “Hey Sarah you still up?”
• “Chris? Yes I'm still up, come in,” she said as she ruffled her blanket in her bed.
• “You have a good time tonight?”
• She sighed and closed her eyes. “I had the best time ever, this was the most wonderful night of my life.”
• “Listen, someone stole my hat and that sword you let me borrow, but I'll replace it, whatever it cost, I promise.”
• She looked at me and smiled and blushed as she looked away, which confused me. “What is it, why are you smiling?”
• She reached under her blanket and pulled out my hat and the sword. “You mean this hat and sword?”
• “What, how did you get those? I had them in the room with Bat-,” I just stopped talking.
• She bit her lip and shook her head yes at me.”It's Catwoman, not Batgirl.”
• After a while it all came together. “Are you telling me I not only fucked my two best friends, but my little sister too!”
• *****
• I just came from a party where I had sex for the first time, and had my first threesome. Not only did I find out afterwards that I had sex with my two best friends, but now I find out I lost my virginity to my very own little sister, in front of a crowd of people, this has quickly turned into a craziest night ever.
• “We had sex? Us? And in front of everyone! Oh my god what if someone recognized us?”
• “No one knew who we were, except my friends, and they won't say anything.”
• “How do you know? Sometimes secrets just slip out, what makes you so sure they'll keep quiet?”
• “Because they're my friends, and I trust them, and I have dirt on both of them much worse.”
• “Worse than what we did? What they do, rob a bank? Must be a pretty big secret.”
• “Its pretty big.” She sighed and gave me a pouty face. “Are you mad at me Chris?”
• It was my turn to sigh as I sat down next to her. “No I'm not mad, just confused. We committed incest Sarah, what we did was illegal, and you were drunk, so I pretty much took advantage of you.”
• “I wasn't drunk Chris, I was only pretending to be. I drunk apple cider and two cups of vodka the whole night, and you didn't take advantage of me, I planned on having sex with you.”
• “Planned it? Well I guess it makes sense now, but why?”
• “Because I knew you wouldn't sleep with your own sister under normal circumstances. I've wanted you for a long time, and when I heard Matt was throwing a party I saw my chance, so I got him to invite me and came up with a plan on how I could finally get you.”
• “But why did... wait what?! Did Matt know you wanted to sleep with me? Did he help you?”
• “No he didn't know, he didn't even wanna invite me because of the kind of party it was and since you were going, but I begged him until he made me a flier, he didn't know about anything.”
• “Oh, good,” I said calming down. “I'm still a little uneasy, I mean were related Sarah, were family, with the same blood, and we had sex! Doesn't that bother you even a little?”
• “It doesn't bother me one bit. I don't care that were related, I love you and I wanted to do this. If you want me to feel guilty for having sex with you I won't. I am sorry for the way I did it, but I'm not sorry at all that I did it, I just hope you're not too mad at me,” she said hanging her head down.
• I put my arm around her and kissed her forehead. “Come on, you know I could never get mad at you, its just a lot to take in. Its not every day you find out your first time was with your sister.
• Her face lit up as she smiled at me. “I was your first?”